Yellow Sigatoka resistance – Goldfinger mutagenesis trial

Yellow Sigatoka screening - Goldfinger mutagenesis trial

Katie Robertson, Jeff Daniells, David East and Carole Wright, Queensland DAF (Dec 2023)

The screening trial assessing Goldfinger mutant selections’ resistance or susceptibility to the fungal leaf disease, yellow Sigatoka is now complete. Most of the selections had a similar reaction to yellow Sigatoka as the Goldfinger control, however GMS 766 was significantly more resistant, while four others were significantly more susceptible. This latter result demonstrates that mutagenesis can significantly change a plant’s level of yellow Sigatoka resistance.

An estimated $25-30 million per year is spent on controlling yellow Sigatoka leaf spot (Pseudocercospora musae) Identifying varieties with better resistance to the disease, provided they were otherwise commercially viable, would be of great benefit to the industry by reducing input costs and reliance on fungicides. 

Over the 2023 wet season, a yellow Sigatoka screening trial was conducted at the South Johnstone Research Facility on the top-twenty Goldfinger selections which had been developed through DAF’s mutagenesis project.

The block had been nurse suckered to standardise plant development stage. Leaf disease control ceased a few months prior to nurse suckering to build up inoculum levels and ensure adequate disease pressure. Plants were assessed for severity of leaf spot disease on 3 occasions, at monthly intervals leading up to bunching. The assessment consisted of determining the Youngest Leaf Spotted (10 or more mature necrotic lesions (YLS), and the Youngest Leaf with greater than 33% of the leaf lamina destroyed by disease (YL33). The Total number of Functional Leaves (TFL) was recorded if the disease was not present or had not progressed to the >33% necrosis severity level. For the purposes of this article, only the YLS and TFL data will be discussed.

While Goldfinger has resistance to black Sigatoka, this is not the case for yellow Sigatoka, to which it is better described as having an intermediate reaction.  Of particular interest was how the new selections compared to Goldfinger and the possible effect mutagenesis may have had on the plants ’ reaction to this disease.  Figure 1 below shows the average YLS of Goldfinger was 6.4, which was similar   to fifteen of the twenty mutant selections. ‘GMS 766’ was the only selection that demonstrated better resistance to leaf spot than Goldfinger, having an average YLS of 7.9.  

On the other end of the spectrum, ‘GMS 602’, ‘GMS 211’, ‘GMS 145’, and ‘GMS 255’ had average YLS values of between 5.4 and 4.4, demonstrating  they were significantly more susceptible to the disease. Although not the original objective of the project, these results demonstrate mutagenesis can significantly change a plant’s level of yellow Sigatoka resistance. The dwarf Lady Finger selection ‘Dwarf Rossi’ was planted as a single guard plant at the beginning of each row of Goldfinger. 

The level of disease was comparable to the ‘Dwarf Rossi’ plants in the variety evaluation, allowing comparisons to be made between the two trials. It was not significantly different to Goldfinger in its reaction to yellow Sigatoka. 

Figure 1: Youngest leaf with 10 or more necrotic lesions (YLS) for the 20 Goldfinger Mutant Selections, standard Goldfinger, and the Lady Finger variety ‘Dwarf Rossi’ (average of 3 rating occasions; error bars represent +/-1 standard error ). The different coloured bars indicate varieties that were statistically similar (yellow) or significantly different (red/green) to Goldfinger (patterned fill).
This research has been funded as part of the project Improved Plant Protection for the Banana Industry (BA16001), which is funded by Hort Innovation, using the banana research and development levy, co-investment from the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries and contributions from the Australian Government. Hort Innovation is the grower-owned, not-for-profit research and development corporation for Australian horticulture. 
Hort innovation logo

Yellow Sigatoka resistance – agronomic evaluation trial (October 2020)

Yellow Sigatoka screening - agronomic evaluation trial (October 2020)

Katie Robertson, Jeff Daniells, David East, and Carole Wright, Queensland DAF (Dec 2023)

The screening trial assessing new varieties’ resistance or susceptibility to the fungal leaf disease, yellow Sigatoka is now complete. Varying degrees of leaf spot resistance were observed among the Cavendish (highly susceptible), Lady Finger (intermediate resistance) and CIRAD hybrids (resistant).

An estimated $25-30 million per year is spent on controlling yellow Sigatoka leaf spot (Pseudocercospora musae) in Australian banana plantations. Identifying varieties with better resistance to the disease, provided they were otherwise commercially viable, would be of great benefit to the industry, by reducing input costs and reliance on fungicides.

Over the 2023 wet season, a yellow Sigatoka screening trial was conducted at the South Johnstone Research Facility. This was after the agronomic assessments on 15 varieties had been completed in the 2020 Variety Evaluation and the block was nurse-suckered. 

Leaf disease control ceased a few months prior to nurse suckering to build up inoculum levels and ensure adequate disease pressure. Plants were assessed for severity of leaf spot disease on 3 occasions, at monthly intervals leading up to bunching. 

The assessment consisted of determining the Youngest Leaf Spotted (10 or more mature necrotic lesions) (YLS), and the Youngest Leaf with greater than 33% of the leaf lamina destroyed by disease (YL33). 

The Total number of Functional Leaves (TFL) was recorded if the disease was not present or had not progressed to the >33% necrosis severity level. For the purposes of this article, only the YLS and TFL data will be discussed.

Figure 1 shows four of the varieties had comparable disease severity to the very susceptible reference variety, ‘Williams’, which had an average YLS of 4.5. These included the TR4 resistant Cavendish ‘Asia Pacific #1’, along with the two tetraploid ‘High Noon’ selections (one with a ‘clean’ rachis [HNC] and one with a ‘dirty’ rachis [HND]) , and the Pendulous Lady Finger selection. 

The other four Lady Finger varieties demonstrated slightly better resistance and were statistically similar to ‘Pacific Plantain’ (YLS = 6.2), which has a documented intermediate level of resistance to leaf spot. Overseas, the hybrid ‘CIRAD 925’ has demonstrated both yellow and black Sigatoka (Pseudocercospora fijiensis) resistance (Risède et al. 2019). 

It was anticipated that the other three CIRAD hybrids may also possess this characteristic, which proved to be the case. Although no leaf spot was present, ‘CIRAD 925’ and ‘CIRAD 918’ only maintained around seven functional leaves throughout the assessments, with older leaves snapping due to petiole weakness, while ‘CIRAD L9’ and ‘CIRAD X17’ sustained over 10 functional leaves. 

The common leaf fungi, Cordana leaf spot (Neocordana musae) and banana leaf speckle (Mycosphaerella musae), were likely present on all varieties, but more obvious along the leaf margins of the CIRAD hybrids due to the absence of yellow Sigatoka. ‘Dwarf Ducasse’ was included as the resistant reference variety and supported an average of 13 functional leaves with no yellow Sigatoka present.

While the CRIAD hybrids remained unaffected by yellow Sigatoka (CIRAD X17 pitcured here), there were other common pathogenic fungi, primarily Cordana and banana leaf speckle present on some older leaves.
The TR4 resistant Cavendish 'Asia Paific #1', was as susceptible as Williams to yellow Sigatoka.
Figure 1 Youngest leaf with 10 or more necrotic lesions (YLS) for 15 varieties at South Johnstone (average of 3 rating occasions; error bars represent +/-1 standard error). If the YLS stage was not reached for a variety (i.e. the CIRAD hybrids and Dwarf Ducasse) the leaf number represents the total number of functional leaves present. Williams (very susceptible), Pacific Plantain (intermediate), and Dwarf Ducasse (highly resistant) were used as references to assess the disease reaction of the new varieties. The different coloured bars illustrate varieties that were statisically similar to the reference varieties (patterned fill).
References
Risède, J.-M., Achard, R., Brat, P., Chabrier, C., Damour, G., Guillermet, C., de Lapeyre., Lœillet, D., Lakhia, S., Meynard, P., Tixier, P., Tran Quoc, H., Salmon, F., Côte, F.-X. and Dorel, M. (2019). The agroecological transition of Cavendish banana cropping systems in the French West Indies. In The agroecological transition of agricultural systems in the Global South. Côte, F.-X., Poirier-Magona, E, Perret, S., Roudier, P., Rapidel, B., Thirion, M.-C, eds. (Agricultures et défis du monde collection, AFD, CIRAD, Éditions Quæ, Versailles). Pp. 107 – 126. https://agritrop.cirad.fr/592993/1/ID592993.pdf 

More information

This research has been funded as part of the project Improved Plant Protection for the Banana Industry (BA16001), which is funded by Hort Innovation, using the banana research and development levy, co-investment from the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries and contributions from the Australian Government. Hort Innovation is the grower-owned, not-for-profit research and development corporation for Australian horticulture.
Hort innovation logo

First ratoon observations and results (2020 agronomic trial)

First ratoon results - agronomic evaluation trial (October 2020)

By Katie Robertson & Jeff Daniells, Queensland Department of Primary Industries

Trends observed in the plant crop (see here) continued in the first ratoon. Williams outproduced the TR4 resistant Cavendish varieties. All the Lady Finger selections performed well compared to the standard Lady Finger, with either improved plant or bunch characteristics and no yield reduction.

Productivity declined in the short statured TR4 resistant Cavendish Asia Pacific #1, while GCTCV 106 continued to perform comparably to Williams.

The yield reduction measured in the plant crop of the TR4 resistant Cavendish variety Asia Pacific #1 (AP#1) was further amplified by the end of the first ratoon. AP#1 yielded 33% less than Williams over the 2 crops (29.3 versus 44.1 kg/year). This was due to their longer cycle time and a lower average bunch weight (26.7 versus 37.9 kg). AP#1 pseudostem height only increased by 8% between the plant crop and first ratoon (2.2 to 2.4 m), remaining significantly shorter than the other Cavendish varieties. Most other TR4 resistant Cavendish selections from Taiwan are taller than Williams. Finger length also remained shorter, with only 17% of AP#1 fruit falling into the premium size grade (22 – 26cm), compared to 56% for Williams. The GCTCV 106 selection – which originated from a vigorous plant identified in the previous 2018 South Johnstone variety evaluation (BA16001) – again performed comparably to Williams with regards to cycle time and yield (see table). Unfortunately, this variety has not demonstrated TR4 resistance in the Coastal Plains (Northern Territory) screening trials (see here for more).

The TR4 resistant Cavendish selection, Asia Pacific #1, remained shorter than Williams with reduced bunch weights, a longer crop cycle and shorter fruit lengths.

There were no yield differences among the six Lady Finger varieties, with some selections displaying reduced pseudostem heights and better bunch conformation.

All Lady Finger selections, except Pendulous Lady Finger (PLF), remained significantly shorter in stature than standard Lady Finger in the first ratoon (11 – 30% shorter). In the plant crop, PLF had yielded 19% more than Lady Finger per 12-months, but by the end of the first ratoon the yields compared over the 2 crops was not different. The standard Lady Finger experienced a 33% increase in bunch weight between the plant crop and first ratoon, going from 12.2 to 18.5 kg, while PLF only had 15% heavier bunches in the first ratoon (17.7 to 20.9 kg). The fruit in PLF bunches took longer to fill (22.3 weeks) than standard Lady Finger (17.1 weeks), and had issues with premature ripening, likely influenced by the timing of bunch emergence and the environmental conditions during fruit filling. Nonetheless, the PLF plants lived up to their name and continued to produce bunches with a more desirable conformation. The four other Lady Finger varieties did not yield significantly differently to the industry standard.

The yield of 'Dwarf Lady Finger' was comparable to standard Lady Finger but was 30% (or 1.4 m) shorter in stature.

The novel hybrids from CIRAD continued to perform poorly in the first ratoon, in terms of bunch size and pseudostem height.

In the plant crop, 40% of the CIRAD hybrid 918 plants had snapped before harvest despite being similar height to Williams. The incidence of pseudostem snapping in this variety rose to 87% in the first ratoon, meaning there were not enough data plants to include in the analysis. The remaining three CIRAD hybrids had bunch weights 25 – 64% lower than Williams per 12-months for the 2 crops, and CIRAD 925 and X17 were taller by 10 and 17%, respectively. X17 has demonstrated a high level of resistance to TR4 in the NT (see here for more).

Where to next?

The trial block was nurse suckered at the beginning of the year to manage the cropping cycle, and the varieties were rated for yellow Sigatoka over the wet season. These results will be reported on later in the year.  

The TR4 resistant CIRAD hybrid X17 yielded 34% less than Williams per 12-months over the two crop cycles.

More information

This research has been funded as part of a project funded by Hort Innovation, using the banana research and development levy, co-investment from the Queensland Department of Primary Industries and contributions from the Australian Government. Hort Innovation is the grower-owned, not-for-profit research and development corporation for Australian horticulture.